Question
Which of these were lessons learned from the Aberfan Disaster?his Choose 3 Managers were unskilled Managers were fit for their roles Miners had no direction relating to risks Dangers to the public were communicated clearly Dangers to the public were overlooked
Answer
3.7
(183 Votes)
Fabian
Master · Tutor for 5 years
Answer
A, C, E
Explanation
The Aberfan Disaster was a catastrophic collapse of a colliery spoil tip that occurred in Aberfan, South Wales, in October 1966. The disaster resulted in 144 deaths, with 116 of them being schoolchildren between 7 and 10 years of age.From the tragedy, several lessons were learned, but to answer your question specifically we need to evaluate each of the given options:1. "Managers were unskilled" - this could be seen as an error if managers did not have technical competency to identify and handle catastrophic risks associated with their work like the stability of the spoil tips.2. "Managers were fit for their roles" - contrastingly, this statement seems to be in opposition to the first point, hinting at adequate worker management but conflicting with the outcomes of the disaster.3. "Miners had no direction relating to risks" - this could have been a lesson learned. It was identified in subsequent investigative reviews, that there had been insufficient practice and attention regarding safety orders among the employees.4. "Dangers to the public were communicated clearly" – this doesn't align with the findings or lessons learned from the disaster.5. "Dangers to the public were overlooked" - in the wake of the disaster, the Davies Tribunal Report identified that numerous warnings about the dangerous instability of the spoil tip had been overlooked, classifying this section as likely aligning with the learnt lessons.