Question
Luca has carried out some research. Who should he ask to peer review it? another scientist who did the research with him his friend his next cloor neighbour other scientists who have studied similar things
Answer
3.8
(215 Votes)
Quentin
Master · Tutor for 5 years
Answer
Other scientists who have studied similar things.
Explanation
## Step 1: Understand the critical cues in the problem. Luca has performed some research and wants it peer-reviewed. Peer review is a process where one's research is evaluated by an expert in the same field to maintain standards and to guard the credibility and integrity of scholarly work.## Step2: The identities of potential reviewers are analysed for their suitability. a) "Another scientist who did the research with him" could add potentially relevant comments. However, involving this person in the review process would neglect a crucial element of peer review: impartiality. b) "His friend" lacks the likely qualification and impartiality to provide a rigorous scholarly assessment. c) "His next door neighbour" likely doesn't have expert knowledge of the research's subject to perform an appropriate review. d)"Other scientists who have studied similar things" is the best possible option. These reviewers would hold the required expertise and shall stand closer to Luca's focus topic, thus enabling them to provide constructive feedback.## Step 3: The next step involves determining the best reviewer based on qualifications and relevance to the research topics. Thus, after analysis, 'Other scientists who have studied similar things' is the most appropriate to review Luca's work