Question
Legal Applications 11. Luis Ramirez owner of an office building in Pittsburgh plans to sue the building's carpenter John Anderson,who also lives in Pittsburgh Luis's new shingle roof leaked and caused moderate damage to the interior walls ceilings, etc. Luis is seeking 70,000 in damages. Luis's attorney has promised to pursue the case through all levels of both the state and federal court systems. Is Luis's attorney making a false promise? Could his case be taken to the U.S. Supreme Court? Explain.
Answer
4.2
(177 Votes)
Nolan
Professional · Tutor for 6 years
Answer
The attorney's promise to pursue the case through all levels of both state and federal court systems does not necessarily mean it's a false promise. However, the likelihood of a case reaching the U.S. Supreme Court is extremely low in a typical scenario like this. For a case to reach the U.S. Supreme Court, it usually needs to involve significant constitutional issues or conflicts of law. A dispute over damages resulting from a leaking roof in a private building is more likely to be resolved at lower court levels, such as state trial and appellate courts. The U.S. Supreme Court typically reviews cases that have broader legal implications or involve constitutional questions.In summary, while the attorney's promise may not be false, it's improbable that this case would reach the U.S. Supreme Court unless it involves unique legal questions or constitutional issues.