Question
5. Can the Constitution be amended in such a manner so as to completely exclude any role for the national government of the United States? Explain why or why not?
Answer
4.3
(310 Votes)
Martin
Elite · Tutor for 8 years
Answer
### No, the Constitution cannot be amended to completely exclude any role for the national government of the United States because the national government is essential to the country's structure and functioning, and the amendment process requires a broad and substantial consensus.
Explanation
## Step1: Understanding the Amendment Process### The U.S. Constitution can be amended through a process outlined in Article V. This process requires either a two-thirds majority in both the House of Representatives and the Senate or a constitutional convention called for by two-thirds of state legislatures. Any proposed amendment must then be ratified by three-fourths of the state legislatures or conventions in three-fourths of the states. This stringent process ensures that amendments reflect a broad consensus.## Step2: Analyzing the Role of the National Government### The national government of the United States, as established by the Constitution, plays a crucial role in maintaining the union, providing for the common defense, regulating interstate commerce, and ensuring the general welfare. The Constitution delineates specific powers to the national government, which are essential for the functioning of the country as a unified entity.## Step3: Evaluating the Feasibility of Excluding the National Government### Amending the Constitution to completely exclude any role for the national government would fundamentally alter the structure of the United States. Such an amendment would not only require an unprecedented level of consensus but would also likely face significant legal and practical challenges. The national government’s roles are deeply embedded in the Constitution and essential for the country's operation.## Step4: Conclusion### Given the essential functions of the national government and the rigorous amendment process, it is highly improbable to amend the Constitution in a manner that completely excludes any role for the national government. The national government is integral to the nation's structure and functioning.