Question
Form and Support Opinions Do you think Truman was justified in dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Explain your answer.
Answer
4.7
(271 Votes)
Jeffrey
Elite · Tutor for 8 years
Answer
The justification for Truman's decision to drop atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki remains a contentious issue. Supporters argue that it hastened the end of World War II, potentially saving millions of lives by avoiding a prolonged invasion of Japan. They also point to the belief that it demonstrated the devastating power of nuclear weapons, potentially deterring future conflicts.However, critics argue that the bombs caused immense civilian casualties and long-term environmental and health consequences. They question the necessity of using such destructive force, especially considering Japan's weakened military position by 1945. Additionally, some argue that diplomatic alternatives, such as continued strategic bombing or a demonstration of the bomb's power, could have been pursued instead.Ultimately, whether Truman's decision was justified depends on one's perspective and the weight given to various factors such as the wartime context, the potential alternatives available, and the ethical implications of using nuclear weapons against civilian populations.