Question
1. Jim was driving home one night after his basketball game when an officer pulled him over. The officer looked long and hard inside his car. then asked if Jim would open up his trunk. Jim said, "Do you have a warrant?" and the officer said, "no." Because of this, Jim told that officer that he would feel more comfortable if he did not search his trunk. Was Jim correct?Why or why not?
Answer
4.4
(278 Votes)
Zara
Elite · Tutor for 8 years
Answer
Yes, Jim was correct. In the absence of a warrant and without probable cause, individuals generally have the right to refuse a search of their vehicle, including the trunk. The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects against unreasonable searches and seizures. Unless the officer has a warrant or valid justification for a search, Jim is within his rights to decline the search.